Defining Manufacturing: Modern Production Blurs the Lines of Economic Value

Thanks to a tip from the NIST-MEP newsletter, we read this new Congressional Research Service report on how the definition of manufacturing may be becoming increasingly outdated.

Traditionally, manufacturing has been defined as the process of physically transforming goods—that is, activities like molding, cutting, processing, and assembly. Many laws, regulations, and trade provisions promoting U.S.-made goods rest on that definition.

But a growing portion of the value of manufactured goods does not lie in this physical transformation. Non-physical inputs like design, research, and software development constitute an increasing share of a good’s value—and also of the employment associated with that good’s production. That trend is expected to continue.

Those jobs, under our current methods of measuring economic activity, are generally not counted as manufacturing jobs. Moreover, the establishments that employ them are often not counted as manufacturing establishments.

At a time when economic policymaking is increasingly concerned with revitalizing U.S. manufacturing and re-shoring manufacturing jobs, this disconnect matters. It has implications for how we measure manufacturing and how we seek to foster the economic benefits of manufacturing activity in our country—and in New York State. Those design, software, business services, and after-sales service jobs matter.

That said, for an economy that has shifted away from manufacturing and toward services over the past several decades, retaining expertise in manufacturing processes remains critical, even if the relative value of those “physical transformation” activities decreases. It’s as important as ever to educate students and the incumbent workforce in next generation manufacturing skills. Our long-term competitiveness depends in part on that expertise, and not divorcing our strength in R&D and design from an ability to remain at the cutting edge of manufacturing processes.

Related Reads from FuzeHub’s Blog

Getting Started with Exporting: What Manufacturers Need to Know
Did you know that 95% of the world’s consumers live outside of the United States? The U.S. remains the world’s
Ask an Expert: John Wen, Head of Industrial & Systems Engineering, RPI
  For this edition of our “Ask an Expert” series, we interviewed Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute’s Dr. John Wen, who plays
Fly Creek Image
Fly Creek Cider Mill: Success Story
About The Fly Creek Cider Mill & Orchard uses a historic, water-power press to turn New York State-grown apples into
MEP in NYS: What Manufacturers Need to Know
Register for our upcoming webinar, Manufacturing Extension Partnership (MEP) in NYS: What Manufacturers Need to Know. Find out what the MEP
4 Things You Need to Know: FuzeHub’s Manufacturing Innovation Fund
Is your New York State manufacturing company looking for grants, funding, or financial incentives to develop a new product or
Manufacturing USA
FuzeHub’s mission is to help small and mid-sized manufacturers in New York State grow through connections to technical and other resources.
Ask an Expert: Imin Kao, Long Island MEP
  For this edition of our “Ask an Expert” series, we interviewed Dr. Imin Kao, who leads the regional New
SBA Accepting Applications for Emerging Leaders Program in Albany
The Small Business Administration (SBA) is bringing its Emerging Leaders Program to Albany, NY this spring. Emerging Leaders is an
Faces of NYS Manufacturing: Bob Bechtold of HARBEC
FuzeHub’s Faces of NYS Manufacturing Series travels to Ontario, New York, where Bob Bechtold of HARBEC is proving that sustainable

Leave A Comment

WordPress Anti Spam by WP-SpamShield